HomeKnowledge HubArtificial IntelligenceGenAI and education: When business profit 'collides' with the mission of nurturing...

GenAI and education: When business profit ‘collides’ with the mission of nurturing people

The boom in generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) forces us to answer a crucial question: what is the true purpose of education? To keep this technology from becoming a "destroyer" of knowledge, GenAI tools need to be reshaped around pedagogical thinking, with teachers as co-design architects rather than passive users.

Our Partner

logo HD Bank

Related

The appeal of GenAI and the risk of “hollow” knowledge

GenAI has quietly but powerfully entered every classroom. Its appeal is undeniable: with a single prompt to ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, an essay, a detailed plan or a summary of a literary classic appears in seconds.

Notably, technology giants often launch free offers for students right at exam time. This is no coincidence; it shows they understand learners’ psychology very well: looking for shortcuts to relieve time pressure and cope with assignments seen as tedious.

But what is the result? When students cannot imagine studying without AI, when every assignment is solved by a machine, are they really “learning”? Or are they merely “outsourcing” knowledge?

This is the fault line between educational goals and business motives:

  • Business: prioritises efficiency, speed, scale and profit.
  • Education: prioritises a slow process, gradual absorption, critical thinking and cognitive maturity.

If we leave education to business logic, we will create a generation of students who are good at producing “products” (assignments) but hollow in thinking (process). “We are prioritising the outputs of teaching over the process of learning,” warns Timothy Cook, a teacher.

Redefining “alignment” in education

In the technology world, “alignment” usually refers to keeping AI from harming people. In education, the concept needs a deeper meaning: alignment between what AI does and the purpose of learning.

An AI tool that writes essays or solves maths problems for students is not an educational tool; it is a substitution tool. To be truly aligned with education, GenAI needs to move beyond being an “answer machine” to become a system of pedagogical support:

  • Detecting disengagement: recognising when students use AI to avoid thinking.
  • Open-ended interaction: instead of giving answers, AI should ask questions back to draw students into the thinking process.
  • Pedagogical empathy: respecting emotional and social needs and helping students overcome difficulties rather than doing the work for them.

Valuing “process” over “product”

The core value of education lies in grappling with knowledge. It is in analysing, debating and correcting mistakes that critical thinking is formed. Self-regulation, the ability to work through difficult tasks independently, matters far more than the final grade.

The sad reality is that current assessment systems (exams, grades) unintentionally encourage the misuse of AI, because they care only about the “product”. To solve this at the root, we need to change how we assess: focusing on progress, the ability to apply knowledge and the learner’s thinking process, rather than simply grading a lifeless piece of work.

Teachers: from users to “co-designers”

The technology industry cannot solve the education problem on its own. AI engineers may be good at algorithms, but they lack the pedagogical sensitivity of an experienced teacher.

The solution is co-design. Teachers should not just be consulted as a formality, but should take part directly in building GenAI tools from the outset.

Instead of building AI that does the work, build AI that acts as a “thought partner”. AI should be designed to spark curiosity and encourage exploration, rather than provide ready-made answers.

Don’t let AI answer for the future

Education is not about transferring a set of correct answers as efficiently as possible. It is the process of forming human beings.

If we continue to design and use AI based on productivity and profit, we will face computer scientist Stuart Russell’s warning: “We will get exactly what we asked for (completed assignments), but not what we wanted (human intelligence).”

The future of education depends on whether we have the resolve to make technology serve human development, and not the other way round.

According to WEF

Read more:

Latest

In this section